The Legal Dos and Dont’s of DIY Home Security Systems

If your home is your castle, it’s worth protecting it with a security system. The wide availability of user-friendly cameras, sensors, and doorbells makes it easy to avoid professional installation and deploy a homemade security system instead. While it provides peace of mind, however, a security system can also create legal problems. Specifically, you could run afoul of privacy laws if you aren’t careful.

We asked three home safety/security experts, K. Campbell, Rob Gabriele and Timothy A. Dimoff CPP for advice. Here’s what they had to say.

Are Security Cameras Legal?

The short answer is yes, but with caveats. For one thing, you usually need a permit, especially if your system is designed to alert the authorities in case of a break-in. “Typically,” says Gabriele, “you install the system first, then your home security company issues you a certificate you can use to obtain the permit. You can be fined should your alarm go off before you’ve filed the necessary paperwork.”

You’re allowed to record video and audio inside your own home, but, says Gabriele, “you are barred from recording in areas where guests should have a reasonable expectation of privacy.” That would include bathrooms and bedrooms.

Outdoors, Campbell advises that there’s no reasonable expectation of privacy in some exterior areas of most properties, such as the front yard (although there might be for specific areas like the pool or spa.) “There’s a difference between pointing a zoom lens camera specifically at a neighbor’s bedroom window, and simply pointing your camera at your front yard which might also capture your neighbor’s yard across the street.”

Fifteen states have specific laws to emphasize privacy issues, and some municipalities and HOAs have their own bylaws, so it’s really important to check with authorities for specific conditions to be met before setting up security cameras on your property.

• Pro tip: If you operate an Airbnb on your property, check out the specific regulations governing security cameras issued by that company.

Are hidden security cameras legal?

Yes, as long as you abide by the general privacy laws discussed above.

Are Security Cameras That Record Audio Legal?

The law handles video and audio recording differently, and regulations concerning audio recording are generally stricter. According to federal law (18 U.S.C. 2511(2)(d)), recording of in-person conversations is legal as long as one person in the conversation consents to the recording. However, some states, including California, Delaware, Florida, Illinois and Maryland, have all-party consent laws, which means that all parties in a conversation must consent to the recording.

Many other states have laws regulating audio recording, so it’s best to be familiar with the laws in your state before setting up a homemade security system that includes audio recording.

Are Security Alarms Legal?

Security alarms are legal, but, again, regulations vary at the state and local levels. Generally, you’ll find what you need to know when you apply for a permit for your homemade security system. In general, an alarm that is audible outdoors cannot sound like an emergency vehicle siren or a civil defense warning system, and some communities require it to shut off automatically after a specified length of time, such as 30 minutes.

Can Law Enforcement Demand My Security Camera Footage?

“In most cases,” says Dimoff, “this happens only with a subpoena. However, most people are very cooperative and will voluntarily turn over security footage to help police solve crimes. It is also to their advantage to turn it over as the issue is in their neighborhood, and it will help law enforcement to keep it safe.”

“Law enforcement,” adds Gabriele, “cannot show up at your front door and demand you hand over footage. This is a violation of the Fourth Amendment and your right to freedom from unreasonable search and seizure.” He cautions that you’ll waive that right by posting footage online or otherwise making it public.

Are Fake Security Cameras Legal?

No law prevents you from installing fake or dummy cameras to deter intruders on your own property. You can, however, incur liability if you have tenants who are under the impression that the cameras work and have a reasonable expectation of protection from them.

About the Experts

• K. Campbell is a security and intelligence professional and a former U.S. military intelligence officer. He is the Principal at Blue Glacier Security &Intelligence LLC.
• Rob Gabriele is the in-house home security and safety expert for SafeHome.org.
• Timothy A. Dimoff is a high-risk security expert who has served on an FBI task force on security. He is a former police detective and President of SACS Consulting, Inc.

Sources

• Airbnb: Informing guests about security devices; 2024.

The post The Legal Dos and Dont’s of DIY Home Security Systems appeared first on Family Handyman.